Last week, Rhode Island Department of Transportation (RIDOT) announced that, from July through the end of the year, Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority (MBTA) commuter rail service will be free for people traveling within the state. The intention of the pilot program is to attract new riders who, in theory, will then realize the convenience of the rail line and continue to utilize it in the future. However, unless you are commuting to and from Boston, commuter rail service in Rhode Island is not very useful. Despite offering three MBTA stations in the state, service proves to be infrequent and unreliable. Lack of coordinated policy in solving transportation problems is a major cause. Large expenditures for highways and extending MBTA service to South County, albeit solving some traffic problems, have failed to eliminate growing traffic congestion throughout the Providence metropolitan area. If some action is not taken, rising immobility may erode the basic economic fiber of the state.
To become more economically independent from Boston and promote more local sustainable development, Rhode Island must develop a stronger public transit system. For example, looking to Amtrak’s Northeast Corridor connecting Providence with Boston, New York City, and Washington, D.C., it is one of the region’s most important transportation arteries. Yet, most Rhode Islanders associate the route only with long-distance commuting, which is an unfortunate association falling far short of its full potential.
By restoring a fourth track on the Northeast Corridor and making some adjustments to existing stations and overpasses, Rhode Island could have a frequent and fast rail shuttle operating between T.F. Green Airport and Pawtucket. The shuttle would operate more like a subway than a commuter rail, by reliably connecting residents of the Providence metropolitan area to jobs, education and medical facilities, as well as commercial and entertainment centers.
The thirteen-mile route would have convenient infill stations throughout to serve local commuters, while the existing stations at T.F. Green Airport and Providence would continue to allow passengers to transfer onto long-distance Amtrak and MBTA trains. A Providence metro rail would also serve to relieve congestion on I-95 and surrounding communities, in addition to providing a solid foundation for decentralizing some of RIPTA’s bus operations. By adding new rail service, RIPTA would have the opportunity to create additional transfer hubs, effectively freeing up valuable space in Kennedy Plaza so it can become a more vibrant and healthy civic center without negatively impacting commuters.
Despite the current political climate not being favorable for federally funded mass transit projects, a few possibilities exist for the state to fund such a project independently. Tax-increment financing and other value capture methods have become increasingly popular in the United States. In Chicago alone, the Cook County Clerk’s Office reported over $5 billion in collected property taxes between 1986 and 2011. Money for a rail project in Rhode Island could also come from congestion pricing for cars traveling between Warwick and Pawtucket (parallel to the Northeast Corridor) during peak commuting hours. While any variation of tolling is usually a tough sell, if the general public understands where the money is going, the idea would be less likely to meet great resistance.
No matter the financing, creating a frequent and reliable rail service in Rhode Island will assist in relieving present and future traffic congestion, protect and enhance property values, increase the mobility of the economy, reduce travel time, and provide a safe means of transportation. Investing in modern and efficient transportation infrastructure is necessary to maintain and grow the state’s economy. Building a rail shuttle between T.F. Green Airport and Pawtucket is a logical first step.
True, but a major part of the dynamic is the “Rhode Island mentality”.
It is thus mentality that:
1- compares the state with a city (Boston)
2- fails to recognize that it is Providence – not Rhode Island – is the economic core of southeastern New England
3- is not aware that the Providence Metro is all of RI and southeastern MA; the 1.6 million person second largest metro in New England
4- fails to understand that the mass transit (rail or otherwise) is Providence based; not state based (a good example is the TFGeen StTion connects OVD airport to the city, Warwick is irrelevant)
Note: RI is not economically dependent on Boston – it is Providence that must achieve a stronger economic (and transit) base for its metro.
Bottom line, the mass transit solution is to recognize that Providence is the core from which roles and incentives must be built.
Thank you for this important and timely message. We need to hear it over & over.
I’ve made no secret of my opposition to Wickford Junction at every single step of the process and maintain that it’s done far more to damage the potential of mass rail transit in Rhode Island than anything else has or will. But, it’s there, and we’re forced to continue utilizing it – so it’s imperative that a mass transit solution actually continue to incorporate Wickford Junction. At minimum, fast and frequent bus service between Wickford Junction and the town of Wickford, East Greenwich, and Jamestown/Newport. South County, with the debatable exception of the 14/65/66 buses, has no functional transit in spite of the fact that many historic points of interest are both very walkable and could be quite transit accessible.
With respect to Steve, I don’t understand what point he’s actually trying to make, because he decries the “Rhode Island mentality” in the same post where he declares all of Rhode Island to be part of the Providence metro area. To be clear, all of Rhode Island is within the Providence metro and far more of Rhode Island (in particular, South County’s historic villages and town centers) needs to be integrated both to Providence in a meaningful way (not by a 90 minute bus ride on a route that runs hourly or less) and also to each other.
We should be running a subway-like (or even Metro-North like) in-state solution for travel between Kingston and South Attleboro (and yes, because South Attleboro is part of the RI Metro area, the trains should run there too), and we should be complementing that all-day frequent shuttle service with strong regional bus routes that connect places that people actually want to go to with the train stations that should have been built to serve them. And we should be partnering with MA and CT to ensure that our regional shuttle train has complementing service on either of its ends, allowing for through travel in either direction – RI trains should meet Shore Line East trains at Kingston, and in partnership with the MBTA a Metro-North style local/express paradigm should be implemented in Providence.
Hi Ryan –
Perhaps we are “talking past” each other.
You make my point is when you state “South Attleboro is part of the RI Metro area…”
It is part of the PROVIDENCE METRO.
There is no “RI Metro area”.
It is the 1.6 million person Providence Metro – all of RI and southeastern MA. That should be our frame of reference – not this state or MA.
So, while I fully agree with all of your transit points, my concern is that until folks shed the RI thing and view all mass transit (and other economic, cultural, social factors) from a PVD Metro view; any comprehensive effort will fail to encompass the full metro area or even to get traction.
The mentality I speak of and dread is a widespread and very parochial, small town, non-metro perspective played out in a state view of life that simply is not relevant to almost all dynamics (including mass transit) except for state law, state government budget, and state taxes).
Part of the reason is the lack of Transit Oriented Development (TOD) in Rhode Island. Under no circumstances should any more residential development be permitted near Providence station, as that allows Providence to act more as a suburb of Boston than a city. Residential TOD should be explored for Pawtucket Warwick and Wickford though. If Wickford was developed more like a mixed use community rather than a walmart strip mall, ridership would likely be double.
Once people get in their cars and have to drive for 10 min or more, they might as well keep driving. If you can get them within a 5-10 min walk of the station, that’s a game changer and what we need in RI to have successful transit network.
“The only way to travel from South County to Providence is by car” is not the outrage that needs to be addressed first.
More outrageous is that most people who live in places like Mount Pleasant or the East Side drive everywhere they ever need to go. Kids are driven to and from school.
There already is a ten mile swath of “Transit Oriented Development” that is not functioning as it should. The many neighborhoods dense enough to support transit need to be covered by a frequent, non-congested bus network (not the current radial system) and safe bicycle routes that actually connect everywhere. Parking policies, zoning policies and economic development subsidies should operate to move shopping out of big boxes and into neighborhoods.
Stop trying to rescue the sunk cost of idiotic Wickford Junction.
There should be a Multi-State Agency that is jointly managed by the Rhode Island & Massachusetts Departments of Transportation Rhode Island Public Transit Authority, Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority, Greater Attleboro & Taunton Regional Transit Authority & Southeastern Regional Transit Authority called the Metropolitan Rhode Island & Bristol County Massachusetts District Commission-Transportation Services.
The Agency will be responsible for Interstate commuter operations between the Providence, Pawtucket & Warwick Metropolitan Area & Bristol County Massachusetts.
Jeffery – The what???
What you are describing is the PROVIDENCE METROPOLITAN AREA – Rhode Island abs southeastern Massachusetts.
Those that name would be simple: Providence Metro Transportation Authority (PMTA).
lol, I’m sorry…. Jeffrey… what?
How about “Metro” for short.
Steve & GGG, The name of agency is not important as the services it provides, these are the following suggestions:
1. An Electric Commuter Tail Line called the Metropolitan Providence & Bristol County Massachusetts Railway or the Trans-Bristol County Line similar to my suggested RIDOT RIPTA & P&W Rhode Island Railway Trans-State & Trans-Metro Line. This rail line will operate between Taunton, Norton Attleboro, South Attleboro Pawtucket Providence & Cranston, then thru a subway between Pawtuxet, under the Providence River, East Providence & Seekonk, then down the medium strip down I195 between Seekonk & Swansea then another subway between Somerset-Ocean Grove, under Mount Hope Bay-Taunton River, Fall River & Westport. Note: The entire line between Cranston-Westport will be called the East Providence-Fall River Subway, then along a rail line between Westport, Dartmouth & New Bedford. The rail line will be using Denver type Silverline V railcars similar to my suggested RI Railway Line. https://a.spirited.media/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2016/07/rtd-denver-silverliner-01-1024×576.jpg The rail line will be also jointly managed by the Rhode Island & Massachusetts Departments of Transportation, Rhode Island Public Transit Authority, Greater Attleboro & Taunton Regional Transit Authority & Southeastern Regional Transit Authority & operated by the Providence & Worcester Railroad.
2. An Airport Commuter Ferry between Fall River & Rocky Point-TF Green Airport also jointly managed by the Rhode Island & Massachusetts Departments of Transportation, Rhode Island Airport Corporation & Southeastern Regional Transit Authority & operated by e Interstate Navigation (aka Block Island Ferry) as part of the Narragansett Bay Commuter Ferry,
3. Electrifying Commuter Rail between Boston, Providence TF Green Airport & Wickford Junction. The rail line will be called the Metropolitan Boston & Rhode Island Commuter Railway or the Ocean Stater which will be jointly managed by the Rhode Island & Massachusetts Departments of Transportation, Rhode Island Public Transit Authority & Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority Commuter Rail.
I forgot to mention the Metropolitan Boston & Rhode Island Commuter Railway will be using AEM7 Electric Locomotives http://www.vistadome.com/trains/amtrak/amt916_aem7.jpg & Hyndi Rodem rail cars https://burbcommunity-morethanthecurve.storage.googleapis.com/2015/04/Double-Decker.jpg
Maybe the name of the agency could be called the Metropolitan Rhode Island & Bristol County Massachusetts Transportation District. Please note, all Transportation within the Providence area on the Rhode Island side is under the jurisdiction of RIPTA.
The name is very important.
What you describe is a tortured way to describe what already exists. The Providence Metro is all of RI and southeastern MA.
Hence, the name is simple:
Providence Metro Transportation Authority (PMTA).
How about the Providence Metro Transportation District
The Metropolitan Providence & Bristol County Massachusetts Commuter Rail & Airport Commuter Ferry Authority.
Just as good…the key is to identify Providence as the core of the service area.
Steve what is your opinion of merging the Rhode Island Public Transit, Turnpike & Bridge Authority & Airport Corporation in as divisions of the Rhode Island Department, like they do in my home state of Massachusetts, with the MBTA, Masspike & Massport in with the Massachusetts Department of Transportation.
One reason for the merger is that the RIDOT & RIPTA can jointly manage a suggested intrastate commuter rail line called the Rhode Island Railway Trans-State (Woonsocket-Westerly) & Trans-Metro (Woonsocket- Wickford Junction & Woonsocket-Quonset Point) Commuter Rail-rapid Transit. https://a.spirited.media/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2016/07/rtd-denver-silverliner-01-1024×576.jpg
The other reason is to also jointly manage the Providence & Newport Ferry & expand the service into a Narragansett Bay Commuter Ferry including expending the Providence-Newport Ferry to Rocky Point (Warwick-TF Green Airport) & the Bay Islands (Prudence & Hog Islands) & developing a Bristol, Bay Islands (Prudence & Hog Islands) & Rocky Pont-Warwick-TF Green Airport Commuter Ferry & taking over the Prudence Island Ferry run.
Correction, Steve what is your opinion of merging the Rhode Island Public Transit, Turnpike & Bridge Authority & Airport Corporation in as divisions of the Rhode Island Department of Transportation, like they do in my home state of Massachusetts, with the MBTA, Masspike & Massport in with the Massachusetts Department of Transportation. Sorry about the typo.
I would support the merging the Rhode Island Public Transit Authority, RI Turnpike & Bridge Authority, and the RI Airport Corporation in as divisions of the Rhode Island Department of Transportation.
Providence Metro Transportaion Authority (PMTA)
RI Turnpike & Bridge Authority
RI Airport Corporation
The one thing I disagree with is any ferry stop in Warwick. Warwick is simply not a destination and Rocky Point is a very poor connection to PVD Green Airport. A PMTA rapid bus and a PMTA commuter rail (not a MBTA line) from the PVD intermodal station to the PVD airport would work best.
In response to Steve’s comment regarding a ferry stop in Warwick, I am attaching the following article from the Rhody Beat regarding the ferry stop at Rocky Point in Warwick: http://rhodybeat.com/stories/ferrys-future-may-include-rocky-point-stop,22515 & the Johnson Sunrise: http://johnstonsunrise.net/stories/ferrys-future-may-include-rocky-point-stop,115136.
It looks like there will be will be a stop at Rocky Point in Warwick. If that happens, RIPTA & the Rhode Island Airport Corporation should look into a having a Rapid Bus Line form the Ferry Terminal, TF Green Airport, Rhode Island & Warwick Malls & CCRI Warwick. In addition, there could be Transit Oriented Development in the old abandoned Rocky Point Amusement Park area similar to the Launch at the Hingham Shipyard in Hingham Ma. https://www.hinghamlaunch.com/ which is connected by an MBTA Commuter Ferry from Boston.
As far as the Providence Metro Transportation Authority is concerned it is a nice Idea, but I like to see an independent bi-state transportation agency that is a partnership of both the Rhode Island & Massachusetts Departments of Transportation, Rhode Island Public Transit Authority, Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority, Greater Attleboro Taunton Regional Transit Authority & Southeastern Regional Transit Authority maybe calling it the Providence & Bristol County Massachusetts Bi-State Transportation District, which would operate independent but work with the Rhode Island Public Transit Authority & the MBTA in providing independent Rail Transit Line called the Metropolitan Providence & Bristol County Massachusetts Railway Trans-Bristol County Commuter Rail (Taunton-Attleboro-Pawtucket-Providence-Cranston-East Providence-Seekonk-Swansea-Fall River-Westport- Dartmouth-New Bedford) & independent Airport Commuter Ferry run between Rocky Point-TF Green Airport in Warwick & Fall River.
Maybe the Greater Attleboro & Taunton Regional Transit Authority in the general Taunton-Attleboro area & the Southeastern Regional Transit Authority can merge as divisions with this Independent B-State Transit District to provide connecting feeder bus service.
I also have another independent Rail Transit proposal for the Commonwealth of Massachusetts (my State Rep & Senator in Everett), Pioneer Valley Transit Authority & Franklin Regional Transit Authority called the Pioneer Valley & Franklin County Regional Light Rail Rapid Transit District aka Springfield Amherst & Greenfield Railway, which is similar to the independent rail transit proposal in the Metropolitan Providence-Bristol County Area, but in will use high platform Siemens-Duwag Light Rail Cars. http://www.hiddenimages.ca/transit/images/medium/CT_SD160.jpg
I am also advocating the MBTA &Boston Harbor Cruises to call their ferry service the Aqua Line.
I hope the discussion on the revived RDOT-Seastreak Ferry Service between Providence & Newport will continue. http://www.gcpvd.org/2009/08/20/ripta-ferry-finally/#comments
First I would want to specify that what I suggest is an for rail part an independent bi state transportation district not an authority that is separate from my suggested Rhode Island Department of Transportation & Public Transit Authority’s Intrastate Commuter Rail aka Rhode Island Railway Trans-State & Trans-Metro Commuter Rail-Rapid Transit Lines & Narragansett Bay Commuter Ferry.
The Bi-State Transit District would jointly include the Rhode Island & Massachusetts Departments of Transportation, Rhode Island Public Transit Authority, Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority Greater Attleboro & Taunton Regional Transit Authority & Southeastern Regional Transit Authority Providence & Worcester Railroad & Seastreak or interstate Navigation.
This Bi State Transit District would include the following:
An independent Electric Rail Transit Line called the Metropolitan Providence & Bristol County Railway Trans-Bristol County (Taunton-Attleboro -Pawtucket-Providence -Cranston-East Providence-Seekonk-Swansea-Fall River-Westport-Dartmouth-New Bedford). Commuter Rail-Rapid Transit Line operated by the Providence & Worcester Railroad & also using Denver Type Silverliner V car similar to the Rhode Island Railway.
An Airport Commuter Ferry Run between Fall River & Rocky Point-Warwick to connect with TF Green Airport. That would also managed by Rhode Island Airport Corporation at TF Green Airport be operated by Seastreak or Interstate Navigation. this ferry service would be also part of the Narragansett Bay Commuter Ferry.
An Electrified MBTA Commuter Rail Line between Boston-Attleboro-Pawtucket-Providence-TF Green Airport-Wickford Junction.
Merging the Greater Attleboro & Taunton Regional Transit & Southeastern Regional Transit as divisions of this Bi-State Transit District to connect with the Metropolitan Providence & Bristol County Massachusetts Railway & Fall River & Rocky Point-TF Green Airport Commuter Ferry.
Second, according to the Rhody Beat: http://rhodybeat.com/stories/ferrys-future-may-include-rocky-point-stop,22515? & Johnson Sunrise; http://johnstonsunrise.net/stories/ferrys-future-may-include-rocky-point-stop,115136 it looks like the Rhode Island Departments Transportation & Environmental Management will be building a ferry dock at Rocky Point. What could be done is that the Rhode Island Department of Transportation Public Transit Authority, & Airport Corporation, along with Rhode Island & Warwick Malls & Community Collage-Rhode Island Warwick Campus could be a Rapid Bus Line between The Ferry Terminal, TF Green Airport, the Interlink, Rhode Island & Warwick Malls & CCRI Warwick.
In addition, there could be some Transit Related Development in the old abandon amusement park area similar to the Launch at the Hingham Massachusetts Shipyard, which connected by an MBTA-Boston Harbor Cruises Commuter Ferry.